Xi-Trump Summits Point to Managed US-China Competition

President Xi’s latest visit to Washington came less than five months after his US counterpart President Trump was in Beijing on a state visit in May this year. The Chinese President’s trip to Washington besides coming too soon, was also very symbolic of a new trend in China-Us relations. While the September bilateral meeting comes amid unresolved questions around; trade, critical minerals, and AI, it points to a model of diplomacy where the Washington-Beijing rivalry is managed through sustained leader-level negotiations other than the traditional American brute force model. As these reciprocal high-level visits abound, they signal a managed form of US-China competition built on mutual interests and strategic cooperation.

The unfolding dynamic of US-China relations speaks to the changing mechanics of the relationship between the world’s largest economies whose consequences often ripple throughout the entire global economy. Reciprocal meetings point to a dynamic where the two sides cannot afford an unmanaged relationship even amidst strategic competition. In a global set up where tensions between the two result in severe risks to global supply chains, constructive relations them are crucial in stabilizing not only supply chains, but also the global economy.

This trend in US-China relations is increasingly shaped by efforts to balance competition and cooperation. For instance, between May and September, trade and technology restrictions have deepened, while strategic competition over semiconductors, AI and critical minerals also continued. During the same time, the situation in the Middle East and Taiwan have also stayed a fundamental sticking point. Nevertheless, economic interdependence also remains significant enough to make economic decoupling untenable. The current dynamic thus, signals a shift towards what Beijing has termed as a constructive relationship. It is a demonstration that even amid intense strategic rivalry, the world’s two most powerful economies can still rely on leader level diplomacy to stabilize relations and the global economic system.

This notwithstanding, we must not judge the reciprocal visits on their ability to alter the strategic competition landscape. Rather, we should view them from the point of view that both nations have a shared appreciation of an entrenched interdependence between them and a collective role in global prosperity. The high-level interactions are the opposite to the “cold war-style” separation; with China showing openness to advancing friendship between its own and the American people. Even when current global power dynamics make competition inevitable, there is still hope in both leaders’ enduring incentive for direct engagement through summit diplomacy. This is highly critical in managing competing interests where both sides acknowledge the serious implications their policies have on each other, but also on the global economy.

The talks in Washington as would be expected were dominated by discussions on Trade, critical minerals, Technology and Security —particularly Taiwan. Meanwhile, the extension of the trade truce that was about to expire in November further proved the usefulness of such engagements in avoiding escalation. The ability for leaders to hold negotiation outside of formal bureaucratic negotiating processes played a supporting role in securing this trade-truce extension. However, one of the outstanding question that remain is whether US-China tensions can be effectively resolved without addressing the underlying dispute, the attempt to contain China’s raise as a global power. Albeit the Washington meeting not rewriting the concessions reached in Beijing, it reached the key milestone -—of  extending the truce which is crucial both for the two parties, but also for global economic stability.

The biggest question that remains unanswered here is whether or not the two powers can reach an agreement. All the same, the trade truce extension in the least allows both sides to stay engaged in negotiations. Moreover, to countries in Africa, Asia and the wider global south, US-China tensions result in both economic and supply chain pressure blighting economic prospects. Beyond constrained supply chains, this friction shrink the diplomatic space, development finance, trade and investment, and technology access. Even when mutual understanding between great powers often results in smaller nations clustering around either power, this rarely negates the opportunities associated with the ability to pursue relations with both.

Therefore, the current trend of reciprocal leader-level engagement, exemplified by the Washington meeting, are efforts to manage US-China competition and a step towards building a framework for managed competition. Summit diplomacy will thus be key in minimizing the risk of escalation and the fallout from it that is disruptive to the global economy. Where US-China tensions, to African mean limited room for diplomatic maneuver and erode development autonomy, the sustained leader-level interaction between both powers reduces economic pressures and the risk of subordinating long term planning to external geopolitical constraints.

The writer is a research fellow at the Sino-Uganda Research Centre.

 

 

 

Xi’s Third Belt & Road Forum Speech Re-affirms China’s Commitment to Building a Community of Shared Prosperity

By Allawi Ssemanda

Last week, the world leaders gathered in Chinese capital Beijing as leaders from over 150 countries, and representatives of international organisations met in Beijing for the Third Belt and Road Forum for International Cooperation. The event also marked 10 years of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Jointly implemented by participating partners, BRI which was initiated by China in 2013 is a high quality public good whose benefits are shared by the world. The project delivers high-standard, sustainable and livelihood-enhancing outcomes globally appreciated.

The project is highly commended for its contribution towards global infrastructure development which has greatly contributed to global connection and easing of trade and the movement of goods and services which has contributed to uplifting of 40 million people out of extreme poverty across BRI economies. This makes the initiative a textbook example of win-win cooperation and shared prosperity which China has always advocated for.

Stressing that the Belt and Road cooperation is based on the principles of “planning together, building together, and benefiting together,” President Xi explained that the BRI “transcends differences between civilizations, cultures, social systems, and stages of development,” adding that “it has opened up a new path for exchanges among countries, and established a new framework for international cooperation.”  “The BRI represents humanity’s joint pursuit of development for all,” observed President Xi.

With this, one can argue that President Xi was spot-on considering study reports about BRI conducted by different independent organisations including major think tanks and the World Bank (WB) whose conclusions contend that BRI is contributing to global development.

The other key area President Xi noted in his speech is the progress the BRI has achieved in green and low-carbon development and addressing climate change challenges. He revealed that this huge public good initiative does not only look at addressing today’s needs by improving connectivity through infrastructure development but it is also keen to addressing environmental concerns as a way of addressing climate change which is key for sustainable development as China continues her efforts of ensuring shared prosperity for mankind. “China has issued documents such as the Guidance on Promoting Green Belt and Road and the Guidelines on Jointly Promoting Green Development of the Belt and Road, and set itself the ambitious goal of forming a basic framework of green development through BRI cooperation by 2030,” Xi announced.  While critics of the BRI have always wrongfully claimed that the initiative is silent about environment, President Xi revealed; “China has also signed an MoU with the United Nations Environment Programme on building a green Belt and Road…, reached environmental cooperation agreements with more than 30 countries and international organizations, launched the Initiative for Belt and Road Partnership on Green Development together with 31 countries, formed the Belt and Road Initiative International Green Development Coalition with more than 150 partners from 40-plus countries, and established the Belt and Road Energy Partnership with 32 countries.”

Further, President Xi also talked about debt sustainability among BRI economies (countries that signed up for the BRI). He explained different ways China has put in place through consultations with partner countries as a way of managing debts so that the project supports wholesomely partner countries without causing economic stress. He stressed that basing “on the principle of equal participation and benefit and risk sharing, China and 28 countries approved the Guiding Principles on Financing the Development of the Belt and Road, encouraging the governments, financial institutions and enterprises of participating countries to attach importance to debt sustainability and improve their debt management capability.”

With aim of avoiding debt burden to BRI economies, China came up with debt sustainability framework for low-income countries. This framework which is endorsed by the World Bank and International Monetary Fund when extending funding and loan facilities looks at among others actual conditions of individual countries. Additionally, while implementing BRI projects, “China has prioritized economic and social benefits and provided loans for project construction based on local needs and conditions. The key areas of investment are infrastructure projects designed to increase connectivity, and projects for public wellbeing urgently needed in participating countries. These have brought effective investment, increased high-quality assets, and boosted development momentum,” Xi stressed.

It is not a surprise that several studies continue to credit BRI projects as catalysts for social-economic development of not just BRI economies but also countries that did not sign up for it but are in corridors of the BRI.  For example, a study by WB conducted in 191 countries, titled “How Much Will the Belt and Road Initiative Reduce Trade Costs?” concluded that the Belt and Road Initiative projects have made trade easier in BRI participating countries by “reducing shipment times and trade costs at country-sector level.”

Examining trade figures from 191 BRI economies and those in BRI corridors and 1,818 cities in BRI economies only, the study concluded that “for Belt and Road economies, the change in shipment times and trade costs will range between 1.7 and 3.2 percent and 1.5 and 2.8 percent, respectively.” Further, the study found that non BRI economies or countries that did not sign up for the BRI are equally benefiting from the initiative stressing that it has led to “reduction in shipment time ranging between 1.2 and 2.5%,” and reduced “trade costs of up to 2.2%.” Also observed by the study was that BRI economies and those countries where BRI projects go through or BRI corridors benefited the most with “shipment times along these corridors decline by up to 11.9% and trade gains by 10.2%,” noted the WB study.

Generally, there is a consensus that the BRI is a public good whose benefits are being enjoyed by a great percentage of mankind irrespective of our respective countries. For example, between 2013 and 2022, the cumulative value of imports and exports between China and BRI economies reached US $19.1 trillion which translates to 6.4% average annual growth, according to a white paper (WT), “The Belt and Road Initiative: A Key Pillar of the Global Community of Shared Future” released by China’s State Council Information Office this month. In this WT, figures indicate steady growth in two-way investments between BRI economies and China which reached USD $280 billion. As of 2022, the value of both imports and exports between BRI economies and China reached USD 2.9 trillion translating to 45.4% of China’s overall foreign trade which represents 6.2% increase if compared with 2013; while the overall value of imports and exports of Chinese private enterprises to BRI economies grew past USD 1.5 trillion which translates to 53.7% of trade between China and BRI economies for the said period.

From her successful experience, China understands the role infrastructure plays while pursuing sustainable development. As two Chinese adage contend; “要想富” , “先修路”; “Better roads lead to better life.” and “Build roads if you want to get rich,” it is clear that it is China’s thirst to contribute in building a community of shared future for mankind in the new era, that with hope of mutual benefits, Beijing embarked on funding this huge public good project  the Belt and Road Initiative to fasten efforts of achieving shared prosperity for mankind in the new era.

Allawi Ssemanda, PhD is Executive Director Sino-Uganda Research Centre and a Senior Research Fellow at the Development Watch Centre.

China’s Medical Diplomacy Reflects President Xi’s Philosophy Of Community With Shared Future For Mankind

My favorite Chinese saying is; “if you want happiness for an hour, take a nap. If you want happiness for a day, go fishing. If you want happiness for a year, inherit a fortune. If you want happiness for a life time, HELP SOMEBODY.” This is a saying that they have taken very seriously!

I needn’t say it but for emphasis I will, a sick nation cannot develop! Imagine you had to go to work with fever, difficulty in breathing, sore throat, aches, pain and cough. Currently, the world is faced with the COVID-19 pandemic that has brought the entire world to its knees. We have been taught that prevention is better than cure and we agree but what if we can’t entirely prevent a disease because its airborne and yet we still have to walk around looking for food. The next option would be going for a cure except there isn’t one and that’s why high-income countries with sophisticated medical systems that a country like Uganda can only admire have terribly crushed down. If something befalls the jungle and leaves the lions down, the sheep don’t go running around, they take shelter. It brings us down to the only shelter that we have learnt with time about the noble disease, vaccinating. What this does is to reduce transmissibility and mortality and prevent the severe form of the disease.  All that has to be done is to vaccinate the highest percentage of the population so that even those that haven’t been vaccinated benefit from herd immunity.

Unfortunately for developing countries like Uganda, purchasing covid-19 vaccines has proved to be a very difficult, since developed countries pre-ordered almost all produced vaccines and others opted to hoard them until all their citizens are fully immunized. This has left many countries including Uganda unable to access these vaccines on market on top of the vaccines being super expensive. Even Covax facility which was started to help developing countries vaccinate their citizens experts say it vaccines at their disposal now cannot even vaccinate 20% of population in developing countries. This means developing countries like Uganda cannot fully vaccinate their citizens without support of other developed countries.

This means many developing countries are going to continue struggling in terms of health capacity and hence, the need for support. In sprit of Ubuntu and Chinese president’s philosophy of a community with shared future for mankind, also known as community of common destiny for mankind, China has embraced medical diplomacy by donating 300,000 doses of the vaccine to Uganda. Also earlier donated to support Uganda’s health sector in the wake of Covid-19 pandemic are; 20 tons of cornmeal, mattresses, sanitizers, blankets, masks, gloves. Even Chinese individual citizens such as Jack Ma himself, a successful entrepreneur that has inspired many Ugandans donated medical supplies. All the above extended in times of need is a clear evidence that friends in need are our friends indeed!

These vaccines are going to go a long way in relieving the effects of COVID-19 in Uganda. The cases began as numbers which shortly turned into names of people we know. With no particular selection criteria, rich or poor, families have broken down leaving behind orphaned children. The people are mostly senior citizens like Uganda’s ambassador to Sudan that are not only important to their families as bread winners but also crucial to the development of the country. The people they leave behind commonly drop out of school, can’t find food and its not rare that they become depressed. These are gaps that will never be filled. We have all been depressed because of loosing someone we know. These vaccines are a strong thread of hope to ending this otherwise unending nightmare.

Currently, Uganda is under lockdown. During the recent presidential address, schools will remain closed and the situation reassessed after 60 days. Before this second lockdown, millions of students did not report to school despite the opening of schools meaning that these dropped out. These are children who are highly motivated with dreams that they wanted to see through. Some of them like me, are the only educated people in their families with a strong desire to finish school and break their families free from the chains of poverty. The awareness that some of the young girls are ending up with teenage pregnancies or being married off as early as 14 years breaks me down to the bones. The opening of schools has been coupled to the vaccination of a significant percentage of the teachers and students. These vaccines will give a huge forward push towards opening up of schools.

A high proportion of Ugandans meet their expenses from their daily incomes. Having a lock down therefore means that they will run short of food, rent, name it. It would really be unfortunate for such a person to catch the severe form of the disease which the vaccine prevents. How can someone who is struggling to find the days food afford 5 million Uganda shillings which is the daily bill of a private hospital to manage someone who is critically ill? This is why we are so thankful for the vaccines from China.

They haven’t only began boosting the medical system of Uganda since the pandemic. China has over the past 36 years donated medical equipment worth $8 million. They didn’t just dump the equipment here! They likewise sent 21 teams of over 200 doctors to show us how to use these equipment and work in our hospitals too. China has also been a significant part of the Ebola emergency prevention and control program that has prevented Ebola outbreaks in Uganda or the spread of outbreaks from Congo. China built the center for disease control. This puts Uganda at a better position, a head of local epidemics due to the preventive nature of the facility. The china-Uganda friendship hospital built in 2012 has reduced maternal mortality rate by 99%, operated on over 7,000 patients and delivered 22,000 mothers annually. These are people who walked into the gates of the hospital full of agony, desperation, uncertainty and trying to find something to hold onto. They walked out of the gates as though reborn, with smiles and full of hope ready to pursue their dreams. As a medical student, I haven’t known more joy than that of patients improving because that’s the call and nobility of the medical profession.

Thanks to China, Uganda is now slowly but steadily crawling out of a poor medical system as they are donating very expensive medical equipment, teaching us how to use them and bringing in expertise and practices that made them breakthrough. It won’t be long till we are there. A dream becoming true!

 Joseph Nyero is a fourth-year medical student at Makerere University and a research fellow at Development Watch Centre, a Foreign Policy Think Tank.